 Research
 Open access
 Published:
Bifurcation and optimal control analysis of a delayed drinking model
Advances in Difference Equations volume 2020, Article number: 522 (2020)
Abstract
Alcoholism is a social phenomenon that affects all social classes and is a chronic disorder that causes the person to drink uncontrollably, which can bring a series of social problems. With this motivation, a delayed drinking model including five subclasses is proposed in this paper. By employing the method of characteristic eigenvalue and taking the temporary immunity delay for alcoholics under treatment as a bifurcation parameter, a threshold value of the time delay for the local stability of drinkingpresent equilibrium and the existence of Hopf bifurcation are found. Then the length of delay has been estimated to preserve stability using the Nyquist criterion. Moreover, optimal strategies to lower down the number of drinkers are proposed. Numerical simulations are presented to examine the correctness of the obtained results and the effects of some parameters on dynamics of the drinking model.
1 Introduction
In recent years, with the improvement of our living standards, life styles are becoming more and more diversified, and drinking plays an increasingly important role in people’s daily life. However, the current situation of alcoholism around the world is really worrying. Taking China as an example, from the statistical data in the white paper on the status of moderate drinking among Chinese drinkers in 2017 [1], the drinking rate of men and women is 84.1% and 29.3%, respectively. It also points out that 65% of drinkers show unhealthy drinking and the main problem is excessive drinking. Alcoholism has become one of the public health and social problems considered by the world. The harm of alcoholism is very serious. Alcoholism may not only have a serious impact on the brain, nervous system, liver, stomach, and heart, but it also accelerates the spread of AIDS and sexually transmitted diseases. And it can also lead to traffic accidents, social violence, and other serious consequences of criminal acts. It is reported that more than 3 million people died because of alcohol, which accounts for 5.3% of all deaths [2]. Therefore, alcoholism is not only a serious global public health problem, but also a social problem to be solved.
Healthrelated risky behaviors related to addictions can be regarded as treatable contagious diseases since they can spread through the social interaction [3, 4]. It is worth mentioning that healthrelated risky behaviors such as smoking [5–11] and drug abuse [12–16] have been explored by mathematical modeling method. In the same way, some drinking models [17–22] based on differential equations have been developed to describe the spreading law of drinking dynamics since the pioneering work of [23]. Specially, there are also some models considering the impact of social environment on drinking spread. Huo and Zhang [24] established a drinking model taking into account the influence of Twitter and showed that Twitter can affect the spread of drinking. Xiang et al. [25] formulated a drinking model considering the effects of public health educational campaigns and demonstrated that the public health educational campaigns can slow down the drinking dynamics. Recently, Xiang et al. [26] proposed the following drinking model considering the effect of immigration on drinking behavior:
where \(P(t)\), \(L(t)\), \(S(t)\), and \(Q(t)\) denote the number of moderate drinkers, light alcoholics, heavy alcoholics, and alcoholics under treatment at time t, respectively. Λ is the total recruitment rate due to birth; Π denotes the total number of immigrants; \(q_{1}\) is the fraction of immigrants entering into light alcoholics, and \(q_{2}\) is the fraction of immigrants entering into heavy alcoholics; η, α and β are the contact rates; ϖ denotes the departure rate of light alcoholics among which a proportion p (\(0< p<1\)) accept treatment and the rest \(1p\) enter into heavy alcoholics; μ is the natural death rate; \(d_{1}\), \(d_{2}\), and \(d_{3}\) are the death rates due to drinking; ε, ρ, and ϕ are state transition rates.
Evidently, it is instantaneous for alcoholics under treatment to enter into the compartment of heavy alcoholics in system (1). This is not acceptable in real life. Indeed, alcoholics under treatment may enter into the compartment of heavy alcoholics again due to their own reasons or the influence of other external factors. However, for such a process, it is reasonable that there is usually a certain period due to the impact of the accepted treatment and selfcontrol for alcoholics under treatment. In other words, the alcoholics begin to accept treatment at \(t\tau\), then they may become heavy alcoholics again at time t for some reason. From another perspective, in comparison with ordinary differential equations, delayed differential equations present more complex dynamics. In fact, delayed differential equations have been applied in various fields, for example, mathematical biology [27–30], epidemiology [31–33], and computer virus [34–37]. All the work above revealed that delay can influence dynamics of the systems significantly. Inspired by the above consideration and related research work, we investigate the following delayed drinking model:
where τ is the temporary immunity delay for alcoholics under treatment due to the impact of the accepted treatment and selfcontrol.
2 Existence of Hopf bifurcation and local stability analysis
Applying the results in [26], it can be obtained that system (2) has drinkingpresent equilibrium \(E_{*}(P_{*}, L_{*}, S_{*}, Q_{*})\), where
with
and \(L_{*}\) is the positive root of Eq. (3)
where
The associated characteristic equation at \(E_{*}(P_{*}, L_{*}, S_{*}, Q_{*})\) is
where
with
When \(\tau=0\), Eq. (4) becomes
with
Clearly, if \(\Xi_{0}>0\), \(\Xi_{1}>0\), \(\Xi_{3}>0\), and \(\Xi_{1}\Xi_{2}\Xi_{3}>\Xi _{1}^{2}+\Xi_{0}\Xi_{3}^{2}\), then Eq. (5) has negative real roots when \(\tau=0\). Next, if \(\lambda=i\omega\) (\(\omega>0\)) is the solution of Eq. (4), it leads to
It follows that
where
Put \(\omega^{2}=\zeta\). Equation (7) becomes
If \(Z_{0}<0\), then Eq. (8) has at least one positive root. We suppose that Eq. (8) has four positive roots, represented by \(\zeta_{1}\), \(\zeta_{2}\), \(\zeta_{3}\), and \(\zeta_{4}\), respectively. Then \(\omega_{i}=\sqrt{\zeta_{i}}\) (\(i=1, 2, \ldots, 4\)) are the roots of Eq. (7). Then, by Eq. (6), we get
where
Define
Then Eq. (7) has a pair of purely imaginary roots \(\pm i\omega_{0}\) when \(\tau=\tau_{0}\).
Going forward, to obtain a condition for the occurrence of Hopf bifurcation, we differentiate both sides of Eq. (4) concerning τ, it can be achieved that
with
Then we claim that
Hereby, we have
where \(F(\zeta)=\zeta^{4}+Z_{3}\zeta^{3}+Z_{2}\zeta^{2}+Z_{1}\zeta+Z_{0}\) and \(\zeta _{0}=\omega_{0}^{2}\). It is apparent that if \(F^{\prime}(\zeta_{0})\neq0\) then \(\operatorname{Re}[d\lambda /d\tau]_{\tau=\tau_{0}}\neq0\), which indicates that the transversality condition is matched.
In accordance with the discussion above and the Hopf bifurcation theorem in [38], we establish the following results.
Theorem 2.1
If \(\tau\in[0, \tau_{0})\), then the drinkingpresent equilibrium \(E_{*}(P_{*}, L_{*}, S_{*}, Q_{*})\)in system (2) is locally asymptotically stable; a Hopf bifurcation at the drinkingpresent equilibrium \(E_{*}(P_{*}, L_{*}, S_{*}, Q_{*})\)is observed by system (2) whenever \(\tau=\tau_{0}\).
3 Numerical simulations of Hopf bifurcation
We choose the same parameters as the ones used in literature [26]: \(\Pi=0.3\), \(\Lambda=0.12\), \(\varepsilon=0.1\), \(\eta=0.6\), \(\alpha=0.3\), \(\beta=0.2\), \(\rho=0.8\), \(\phi=0.226\), \(p=0.3\), \(\varpi=0.583\), \(\mu=0.1595\), \(d_{1}=0.02\), \(d_{2}=0.038\), \(d_{3}=0.03\), \(q_{1}=0.4\), \(q_{2}=0.3\). System (2) turns into
Equation (3) turns into
which leads to the drinkingpresent \(E_{*}(0.1967, 0.7583, 0.9432, 0.3495)\). Based on Eq. (8) and Eq. (10), we get \(\omega_{0}=0.1644\) and \(\tau_{0}=2.7958\) with the aid of Matlab software package. As exhibited in Fig. 1, the drinkingpresent equilibrium \(E_{*}(0.1967, 0.7583, 0.9432, 0.3495)\) is locally asymptotically stable when we fix \(\tau=2.6865\). However, when the fixed value of the delay exceeds \(\tau_{0}=2.7958\), the drinkingpresent equilibrium \(E_{*}(0.1967, 0.7583, 0.9432, 0.3495)\) loses stability and the specific case of system (2) experiences a Hopf bifurcation, which can be depicted by Fig. 2. In what follows, we are interested in focusing on the effects of some other parameters on dynamics of system (2).

(i)
The number of moderate drinkers decreases as the value of Π increases, whereas the number of light alcoholics, heavy alcoholics, and alcoholics under treatment increases, which can be displayed in Fig. 3.

(ii)
The number of moderate drinkers and heavy alcoholics decreases; however, the number of light alcoholics and alcoholics under treatment increases when the value of p or ϕ increases. This phenomenon can be exhibited in Figs. 4 and 5. It is also interesting to note that the system changes from stable state to limit cycle as there is a decrease in p or ϕ, which can be observed in Fig. 6 and 7.

(iii)
The number of moderate drinkers and alcoholics under treatment increases due to the increase of ρ; nevertheless, the number of light alcoholics and heavy alcoholics decreases, which can be shown in Fig. 8. It can also be found in Fig. 9 that the system will lose stability and exhibits limit cycle due to the increase of ρ.
4 Estimation of the length of delay to preserve stability
Let the initial condition for system (2) be
We consider the set of all realvalued continuous functions defined on \([\tau, \infty)\), those satisfy the initial conditions (16). Using the substitutions \(u_{1}=PP_{*}\), \(u_{2}=LL_{*}\), \(u_{3}=SS_{*}\), and \(u_{4}=QQ_{*}\), the linearized form of system (2) is given by
where the expression for \(P_{ij}\), \(i, j=1, 2, 3, 4\), is given in Sect. 2 before Eq. (5). Now, the Laplace transform of system (17) is as follows:
where \(K(s)=\int_{\tau}^{0}e^{s\tau}u_{4}(t) \,dt\) and \(\bar{u}_{i}(s)\) are the Laplace transforms of \(u_{i}(t)\), \(i=1, 2, 3, 4\), respectively. To reach our objective, we use the Nyquist criterion for local stability and follow the lines of [28]. The characteristic equation of system (18) is of the form
where the forms of \(\Upsilon_{i}\) and \(\Psi_{i}\), \(i=0, 1, 2, 3\), are given in Sect. 2 after Eq. (4). Let \(s=i\eta\), and separating the real and imaginary parts, we get
and
Using the Nyquist criteria for local stability, we have
and
where \(\eta_{0}\) is the smallest positive root of Eq. (22). If the relations in Eq. (22) and Eq. (23) hold simultaneously, then system (18) as well as system (2) are stable. Using these to estimate the delay τ, we now find the upper bound \(\eta_{+}\) on \(\eta_{0}\) which is independent of τ and satisfies the relations in Eq. (23) ∀η, \(0\leq\eta\leq\eta_{+}\) at \(\eta=\eta_{0}\). Now, we assume \(\sin\eta_{0} \tau\leq1\) and \(\cos\eta _{0} \tau\leq1\), then from Eq. (22) we get
Let \(\eta_{+}\) be a positive solution of Eq. (24) such that \(\eta _{0}\leq\eta_{+}\). Therefore, from Eq. (23) we get
Now, substituting Eq. (22) in Eq. (25) and rearranging, we get
Now,
and
Let us denote
and using Eq. (27) and Eq. (28), from Eq. (26) we get
Thus from (29) we have \(0\leq\tau<\tau_{+}\), where
From Eq. (30), we can determine the length of the delay (τ) where the stability is preserved.
5 Optimal control analysis
We considered an optimal control model for the drinking model. In this model, control is education or media coverage, which changes the behavior of certain individuals in the heavy alcoholics class. This change in behavior leads to subdividing heavy alcoholics into three subclasses, namely S, \(S_{1}\), and \(S_{2}\). A proportion of the heavy alcoholics populations S decide to change their behavior due to the effect of a successful education campaign and thus enter the \(S_{1}\) or \(S_{2}\) class. These two classes \(S_{1}\) and \(S_{2}\) have lower transmission rates than the S class and will contribute to lowering the number of moderate drinkers.
We consider optimal control of an ordinary differential equation model, which describes the interaction of education with heavy alcoholics as follows:
with the initial conditions
where \(\sigma\in(\tau,0]\).
In the above optimal control model, we need three rates \(\alpha _{1}\), \(\alpha_{2}\), \(\alpha_{3}\) for S, \(S_{1}\), and \(S_{2}\) respectively for their interactions with the class P. We also state transition rates \(\phi_{1}\), \(\phi_{1}\), \(\phi_{1}\). Notice that, as a result of interactions of individuals in class S with the control, education \(u(t)\), a proportion of heavy alcoholics leave the general heavy alcoholics class S and move to \(S_{1}\) and \(S_{2}\). The rate of moving into class \(S_{i}\) for \(i=1,2\) is \(\lambda_{i}u(t)S(t)\).
Now, we will focus on the use of the variable control function \(u(t)\), which represents the level of education or media coverage and enables heavy alcoholics to change their behavior.
Our goal is to find the control \(u(t)\) and associated state variables \(P(t)\), \(L(t)\), \(S(t)\), \(S_{1}(t)\), \(S_{2}(t)\), and \(Q(t)\) to minimize the following objective functional:
The control set u is
where \(0\leq u_{\mathrm{min}}(t)< u_{\mathrm{max}}(t)\leq1\), C is weighted costs associated with the use of the control \(u(t)\).
In this subsection, we derive the first order necessary conditions for the existence of optimal control by constructing Hamiltonian H and then applying Pontryagin’s maximum principle. To simplify the notations, we write \(\mathbf{x}(t)=[P(t),L(t),S(t),S_{1}(t),S_{2}(t),Q(t)]^{T}. {\boldsymbol{\rho}}(t)=[\rho_{1}(t),\rho_{2}(t),\rho_{3}(t), \rho_{4}(t),\rho_{5}(t),\rho_{6}(t)]^{T}\). The Hamiltonian is given by
Let \(\chi_{[t_{1},t_{2}]}(t)\) be the characteristic function defined by
Let \(\mathbf{u}^{\ast}\) be the optimal control and \(\mathbf{x}^{\ast}=[P(t),L(t),S(t),S_{1}(t),S_{2}(t),Q(t)]^{T}\) be the corresponding optimal trajectory. Then there exists \({\boldsymbol{\rho}}(t)\in\mathbb{R}^{6}\) such that the first order necessary condition for the existence of optimal control is given by the equation
Now we apply the necessary conditions to the Hamiltonian H in (32).
Theorem 4.1
Let \(P^{*}\), \(L^{*}\), \(S^{*}\), \(S_{1}^{*}\), \(S_{2}^{*}\), \(Q^{*}\), \(u^{*}\)be optimal state solutions with associated optimal control variables \(u^{*}\)for the optimal control problem. Then there exist adjoint variables \(\rho_{i}\), \(i=1,2,3,4,5,6\), from the above equation, we obtain
with transversality conditions (or boundary condition)
Furthermore, optimal controls \(u^{*}\)are given by
Proof
To determine the adjoint equation and the transversality condition, we use the Hamiltonian in Eq. (32). From setting \(P(t)=P^{*}(t)\), \(L(t)=L^{*}(t)\), \(S(t)=S^{*}(t)\), \(S_{1}(t)=S_{1}^{*}(t)\), \(S_{2}(t)=S_{2}^{*}(t)\), and \(Q(t)=Q^{*}(t)\), differentiating the Hamiltonian in Eq. (32) with respect to P, L, S, \(S_{1}\), \(S_{2}\), Q, respectively, we obtain Eq. (33) and Eq. (34). By solving the equations and using the optimality conditions and the property of the control space \(\mathbb{U}\), we derive Eq. (36).
Here we call formulas in Eq. (36) for \(u^{*}\) the characterization of the optimal control. The optimal control and the state are found by solving the optimality system, which consists of the state system Eq. (31), the adjoint system Eq. (34), initial conditions at \(t = 0\), boundary conditions Eq. (35), and the characterization of the optimal control Eq. (36). To solve the optimality system, we use the initial and transversality conditions together with the optimal control given by Eq. (36). □
6 Simulations of optimal control strategy
In this section, the drinking model optimal system is solved using Euler’s method. The optimal strategy is obtained by solving the state and adjoint systems and the transversality conditions. When viewing the graphs, remember that each of the individuals without control is marked by blue solid lines. The individuals with control are marked by red dash lines. The weight constant value in the objective functional is \(C=0.5\).
Figure 10 represents the behavior time plots of P, L, S, and Q in a system without control and with control. In Fig. 11, we plot the optimal control \(u(t)\) in the system. We select the parameters as follows: \(\Lambda=0.8\), \(q_{1}=0.5\), \(q_{2}=0.3\), \(\Pi=0.6\), \(\epsilon=0.4\), \(\eta=0.9\), \(\beta=0.4\), \(\mu =0.26\), \(\rho=0.8\), \(d_{1}=0.05\), \(d_{2}=0.048\), \(d_{3}=0.04\), \(\varpi =0.583\), \(\phi_{1}=0.4\), \(\phi_{2}=0.2\), \(\phi_{3}=0.2\), \(\lambda_{1}=0.7\), \(\lambda_{2}=0.9\), \(p=0.3\). Time delay is \(\tau=2\). Initial conditions are as follows: \((P(0), L (0), S (0), S_{1} (0), S_{2}(0),Q(0) )=(0.15,0.729,0.52,0,0,0.78)\).
Figure 10 shows that after effective control such as education activities, media coverage, etc., the number of P, L, S, Q is significantly reduced compared with that without control. The results of numerical simulation prove that the effect of media coverage can reduce the number of moderate drinkers, light alcoholics, heavy alcoholics, and alcoholics under treatment in a certain period of time. In particular, the control resulted in a significant reduction in the number of heavy alcoholics.
7 Concluding remarks
Death rate because of drinking has been higher than that of tuberculosis, HIV/AIDS, and diabetes by WTH in 2018. Mathematical modeling has been used to predict the spread of drinking by scholars. During its spread in a particular population, drinking shows different kinds of delays which essentially impact the dynamics. We proposed a delayed drinking model with the effect of immigration by introducing the temporary immunity delay for alcoholics under treatment due to the impact of the accepted treatment and selfcontrol into the model formulated in [26].
By considering the time delay as a bifurcation parameter, we have seen the effect of time delay on the stability of the model. We observe that if the time delay is suitably small under some certain conditions, then the four populations in system (2) tend to the drinkingpresent equilibrium, which indicates that the spread of drinking can be dominated. On the contrary, it will be out of control when the time delay is large enough. Thus, it gives a conclusion that the time delay is harmful for the control of spread of drinking. The numerical simulation shows that system (2) changes its stable state into limit cycle as p or ϕ decreases, which makes it difficult to control the spread of drinking. From this point of view, we should strongly appeal to more and more people to join the team of those abstaining from drinking. On the other hand, it is revealed that system (2) becomes stable as we increase the value of ρ, which indicates that alcoholics under treatment should have strong will.
We also find that the number of light alcoholics, heavy alcoholics, and alcoholics under treatment will increase once the amount of immigrants increases, which gives us a suggestion that we should properly control the immigrants in a particular community. Furthermore, since the number of heavy alcoholics decreases when p or ϕ increases, it is strongly suggested that drinkers should give up drinking and accept treatment as soon as possible, if necessary. However, the number of both light and heavy alcoholics increases with the decrease in ρ. Thus, we can conclude that once the drinkers accept treatment and begin to give up drinking, they should have strong will and selfcontrol, not give up halfway.
Moreover, we study the optimal control of the drinking model. The behavior change of various classes is caused by media coverage and propaganda messages. This work demonstrates the power of public propaganda and is an easy control tool for making relevant propaganda plans and policy decisions.
References
White Paper on the status of moderate drinking among Chinese drinkers in 2017, http://jiu.people.cn/n1/2017/1021/c40632429600703.html (2020). Accessed on 1st May 2020
Global status report on alcohol and health 2018, https://www.who.int/substance_abuse/publications/global_alcohol_report/en/ (2018)
Ma, S.H., Huo, H.F., Meng, X.Y.: Modelling alcoholism as a contagious disease: a mathematical model with awareness programs and time delay. Discrete Dyn. Nat. Soc. 2015, Article ID 260195 (2015)
Ma, S.H., Huo, H.F.: Global dynamics for a multigroup alcoholism model with public health education and alcoholism age. Math. Biosci. Eng. 16, 1683–1708 (2019)
Rahman, G., Agarwal, R.P., Liu, L.L., Khan, A.: Threshold dynamics and optimal control of an agestructured giving up smoking model. Nonlinear Anal., Real World Appl. 43, 96–120 (2018)
Ucar, S., Ucar, E., Ozdemir, N., Hammouch, Z.: Mathematical analysis and numerical simulation for a smoking model with Atangana–Baleanu derivative. Chaos Solitons Fractals 118, 300–306 (2019)
Rahman, G.U., Agarwal, R.P., Din, Q.: Mathematical analysis of giving up smoking model via harmonic mean type incidence rate. Appl. Math. Comput. 354, 128–148 (2019)
Haq, F., Shah, K., Rahman, G.U., Shahzad, M.: Numerical solution of fractional order smoking model via Laplace Adomian decomposition method. Alex. Eng. J. 59, 739–752 (2020)
Harvim, P., Zhang, H., Georgescu, P., Zhang, L.: Cigarette smoking on college campuses: an epidemical modelling approach. J. Appl. Math. Comput. (2020) https://doi.org/10.1007/s1219002001402y
Zhang, Z.Z., Wei, R.B., Xia, W.J.: Dynamical analysis of a giving up smoking model with time delay. Adv. Differ. Equ. 2019, Article ID 505 (2019)
Sun, C.X., Jia, J.W.: Optimal control of a delayed smoking model with immigration. J. Biol. Dyn. 13, 447–460 (2019)
Liu, P.Y., Zhang, L., Xing, Y.F.: Modelling and stability of a synthetic drugs transmission model with relapse and treatment. J. Appl. Math. Comput. 60, 465–484 (2019)
Ma, M.J., Liu, S.Y., Xiang, H., Li, J.: Dynamics of synthetic drugs transmission model with psychological addicts and general incidence rate. Physica A 491, 641–649 (2018)
Ma, M.J., Liu, S.Y., Li, J.: Does media coverage influence the spread of drug addiction? Commun. Nonlinear Sci. Numer. Simul. 50, 169–179 (2017)
Saha, S., Samanta, G.P.: Synthetic drugs transmission: stability analysis and optimal control. Lett. Biomath. 6, 1–31 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1080/23737867.2019.1624204
Nyabadza, F., Njagarah, J.B.H., Smith, R.J.: Modelling the dynamics of crystal meth (‘tik’) abuse in the presence of drugsupply chains in South Africa. Bull. Math. Biol. 75, 24–48 (2013)
Sanchez, F., Wang, X.H., CastilloChavez, C., et al.: Drinking as an epidemic: a simple mathematical model with recovery and relapse. In: Witkiewitz, K.A., Marlett, G.A. (eds.) Therapists Guide to EvidenceBased Relapse Prevention: Practical Resources for the Mental Health Professional, pp. 353–368. Academic Press, Burlington (2007)
Manthey, J.L., Aidoo, A.Y., Ward, K.Y.: Campus drinking: an epidemiological model. J. Biol. Dyn. 2, 346–356 (2008)
Mulone, G., Straughan, B.: Modelling binge drinking. Int. J. Biomath. 5, Article ID 1250005 (2012)
Sharma, S., Samanta, G.P.: Analysis of a drinking epidemic model. Int. J. Dyn. Control 3, 288–305 (2015)
Guo, Z.K., Huo, H.F., Xiang, H.: Bifurcation analysis of an agestructured alcoholism model. J. Biol. Dyn. 12, 1009–1033 (2018)
Huo, H.F., Chen, Y.L., Xiang, H.: Stability of a binge drinking model with delay. J. Biol. Dyn. 11, 210–225 (2017)
Benedict, B.: Modelling alcoholism as a contagious disease: how “infected” drinking buddies spread problem drinking. SIAM News 40, 353–368 (2007)
Huo, H.F., Zhang, X.M.: Complex dynamics in an alcoholism model with the impact of Twitter. Math. Biosci. 281, 24–35 (2016)
Xiang, H., Song, N.N., Huo, H.F.: Modelling effects of public health educational campaigns on drinking dynamics. J. Biol. Dyn. 10, 164–178 (2016)
Xiang, H., Zhu, C.C., Huo, H.F.: Modelling the effect of immigration on drinking behaviour. J. Biol. Dyn. 11, 275–298 (2017)
Bai, Y.Z., Li, Y.Y.: Stability and Hopf bifurcation for a stagestructured predator–prey model incorporating refuge for prey and additional food for predator. Adv. Differ. Equ. 2019, Article ID 42 (2019)
Kundu, S., Maitra, S.: Dynamics of a delayed predator–prey system with stage structure and cooperation for preys. Chaos Solitons Fractals 114, 453–460 (2018)
Bentounsi, M., Agmour, I., Achtaich, N., Foutayeni, Y.E.: The Hopf bifurcation and stability of delayed predator–prey system. Comput. Appl. Math. 37, 5702–5714 (2018)
Duan, D.F., Niu, B., Wei, J.J.: Hopf–Hopf bifurcation and chaotic attractors in a delayed diffusive predator–prey model with fear effect. Chaos Solitons Fractals 123, 206–216 (2019)
Goel, K., Kumar, A., Nilam: A deterministic timedelayed SVIRS epidemic model with incidences and saturated treatment. J. Eng. Math. 121, 19–38 (2020)
Vales, E.A., Perez, A.G.C.: Dynamics of a timedelayed SIR epidemic model with logistic growth and saturated treatment. Chaos Solitons Fractals 127, 55–69 (2019)
Zhang, Z.Z., Kundu, S., Tripathi, J.P., Bugalia, S.: Stability and Hopf bifurcation analysis of an SVEIR epidemic model with vaccination and multiple time delays. Chaos Solitons Fractals 131, Article ID 109483 (2020)
Upadhyay, R.K., Kumari, S.: Discrete and data packet delays as determinants of switching stability in wireless sensor networks. Appl. Math. Model. 72, 513–536 (2019)
Keshri, N., Mishra, B.K.: Two timedelay dynamic model on the transmission of malicious signals in wireless sensor network. Chaos Solitons Fractals 68, 151–158 (2014)
Ren, J.G., Yang, X.F., Yang, L.X., Xu, Y.H., Yang, F.Z.: A delayed computer virus propagation model and its dynamics. Chaos Solitons Fractals 45, 74–79 (2012)
Yao, Y., Xie, X.W., Guo, H., Yu, G., Gao, F.X., Tong, X.J.: Hopf bifurcation in an Internet worm propagation model with time delay in quarantine. Math. Comput. Model. 57, 2635–2646 (2013)
Hassard, B.D., Kazarinoff, N.D., Wan, Y.H.: Theory and Applications of Hopf Bifurcation. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1981)
Acknowledgements
We are very thankful to the anonymous reviewers for their insightful comments and suggestions, which helped us to improve the manuscript considerably. The authors are also thankful to Fei Wang in Qufu Normal University for his great help about the optimal control of the proposed model.
Availability of data and materials
All of the authors declare that all the data can be accessed in our manuscript in the numerical simulation section.
Funding
This research was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of the Higher Education Institutions of Anhui Province (No. KJ2020A0002) and the Project of Natural Science Foundation of Anhui Province (No. 2008085QA09).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
All authors contributed equally. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
It is declared that no competing interest exists among the authors regarding this manuscript.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Zhang, Z., Zou, J. & Kundu, S. Bifurcation and optimal control analysis of a delayed drinking model. Adv Differ Equ 2020, 522 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13662020029871
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13662020029871