 Research
 Open Access
 Published:
Transmissibility of epidemic diseases caused by delay with local proportional fractional derivative
Advances in Difference Equations volume 2021, Article number: 292 (2021)
Abstract
Epidemiological models have been playing a vital role in different areas of biological sciences for the analysis of various contagious diseases. Transmissibility of virulent diseases is being portrayed in the literature through different compartments such as susceptible, infected, recovered (SIR), susceptible, infected, recovered, susceptible (SIRS) or susceptible, exposed, infected, recovered (SEIR), etc. The novelty in this endeavor is the addition of compartments of latency and treatment with vaccination, so the system is designated as susceptible, vaccinated, exposed, latent, infected, treatment, and recovered (SVELITR). The contact of a susceptible individual to an infective individual firstly makes the individual exposed, latent, and then completely infection carrier. Innovatively, the assumption that exposed, latent, and infected individuals enter the treatment compartment at different rates after a time lag is also deliberated through the existence of time delay. The rate of change and constant solutions of each compartment are studied with incorporation of a special case of proportional fractional derivative (PFD). In addition, existence and uniqueness of the system are also comprehensively elaborated. Moreover, novel dynamic assessment of the system is carried out in context with the fractional order index. Succinctly, the manuscript accomplishes cyclic epidemiological behavior of the infectious disease due to the delay in treatment of the infected individuals.
1 Introduction
Mathematical modelling is a significant tool in epidemiology that helps healthcare researchers and policymakers to make public health and socioeconomic decisions. These models are designed by using data collected from clinicians and health workers to make prophecies about a disease’s development. A tremendous number of models have been formulated, analyzed, and applied, which improved our understanding and predictive ability about a variety of infectious diseases [1–5]. Many of these models also consider time delay in the process of transmissibility of any infection to further study the effect of delays on the spread out of diseases. For instance, in [6] authors discussed the traveling wave solutions of agestructured susceptible, exposed, infective, recovered, susceptible with time delay. Zhang et al. [7] generated significant results elaborating the influence of time delay on the stability and measures of synthetic drugs transmission. Liu et al. [8] incorporated incubation time delay in the susceptible, infected, recovered vector, bone epidemic model and discussed its stability with the logistic population growth. Rifhat et al. [9] designed a stochastic SIRV model and explained the effects of environmental noises on the disease transmission. Ameen et al. [10] accumulated an SIRV epidemiological model with fractional optimal control problem, taking proportions of vaccination and treatment as suggested controlling parameters. Thus, literature comprehends many such contributions in the area of epidemiological studies [11–15].
Calculus of noninteger orders has a long and exciting history beginning with communication by two scientists Leibniz and de L’Hopital. Equations with fractional order derivatives are a powerful tool for unfolding processes with nonlocality and memory. Some new definitions of fractional derivatives have a conventional view of nonstandard things that contains violations of the Leibniz rule for the derivative of a product function and the chain rule that describe the composition of a function. Some of these new operators and results are just formal noninteger calculus of the known conventional theories, often without any justification and motivation. There are different types of noninteger derivatives, which describe the processes of nonlocality and memory, that were suggested by Liouville, Caputo, and Reisz [16]. Recently, fractional calculus has been widely applied in many fields such as engineering and sciences [17–20].
Treating an infection sometimes undergoes a delay. Bearing this in mind, in this endeavor a compartment for treated individuals with time delay is integrated in the model. A pictorial representation of the transmission process of the disease among compartments of the proposed model is described in Fig. 1. Accordingly, constructive novel features of the proposed model can be outlined as follows:

Growth of susceptible individuals is defined with a threshold through the perception of logistic growth.

A group of vaccinated individuals is also defined in the system.

Elaboration of the rate of exposed, latent, and infected individuals entering in the treated compartment after a time lag.

The dynamic system of the seven equations is scrutinized in the context with a special case of proportional fractional derivative [19, 21].

Memory effect on the basic reproduction number and the stability of equilibrium points.

Investigation of Hopf bifurcation critical point [11] for the existence of cycles in phase diagrams of the system.
Sequentially, the whole paper is described in seven sections: Sect. 2 comprises details of modelling the aforementioned assumptions with essential theorems. Epidemiological properties, such as basic reproduction number, dynamics of the proposed system, and Hopf bifurcation, are comprehended in Sects. 3, 4, and 5, respectively. Moreover, the analytical discussions are numerically validated through tables and graphs in Sect. 6, which are later concluded in Sect. 7.
2 Modelling
The SIR and SEIR models have undergone different modifications, according to variations of contemporary diseases and developed theories of mathematical modelling. Since these systems deal with the human population, the basic biological assumptions are retained in such models. Here, we adapted a model that consists of seven compartments, where individuals are categorized on the basis of their compartment to ailment. The constructed system is based on the following assumptions:

All individuals, except vaccinated, have equal likelihood to catch infection when they are exposed to the infection.

The vaccinated individuals do not get infected even if they are exposed to the disease.

Population growth of the susceptible is defined with a maximum sustainability to survive in the available resources in an environment.

The susceptible population undergoes two phases of disease diagnosis, i.e., exposed and latency, before becoming completely infective.

Different rates of treatment for exposed, latent, and infected individuals are considered due to a different degree of ailment.

Individuals go for treatment after the contact with infection, therefore the treating compartment will show a delay in dynamics.

After being treated, recovered individuals do not participate in transmitting the disease.

Dynamic changes are evaluated, in particular, with respect to change in the rate of fractional index in time for the considered region.
Articulating these assumptions, the following system of seven nonlinear fractional order differential equations with delay is attained, i.e., susceptible, vaccinated, exposed, latent, infected, treatment, and recovered (SVELITR):
Initial conditions and history functions are assumed to be as follows:
where \(\xi _{i} ( \vartheta ) \ge 0\) and \(\xi _{i} ( 0 ) > 0\) for \(i = 1,2, \ldots ,7\) such that \(( \xi _{1} ( \vartheta ), \xi _{2} ( \vartheta ), \ldots , \xi _{7} ( \vartheta ) ) \in C ( [  \tau ,0 ], \Re _{ +}^{7} )\). All the variables and parameters in system (1) are elaborated in Table 1. Moreover, let \(\aleph ( t )\) be the population of the considered region expressed as
After the exploration of conformable derivative through the concept of proportional controller by Anderson et al. [21], proportional fractional derivative has been undergone with different simplifying properties [19]. The special case of this derivative considered in [19] has great potential to convert the fractional order derivative into an integer order one, which can be scrutinized without any ambiguity [22–24]. According to this development, the fractional operator of any continuous function \(y ( t )\) expands to
where \(\kappa _{0} ( \alpha , t ) \ne 0\) for \(\alpha \in ( 0,1 ]\), with \(\lim_{\alpha \to 0^{ +}} \kappa _{0} ( \alpha , t ) = 0\) and \(\lim_{\alpha \to 1^{ }} \kappa _{0} ( \alpha , t ) = 1\). Additionally, \(\kappa _{1} ( \alpha , t ) \ne 0\) for \(\alpha \in [ 0,1 )\), with \(\lim_{\alpha \to 0^{ +}} \kappa _{1} ( \alpha , t ) = 1\) and \(\lim_{\alpha \to 1^{ }} \kappa _{1} ( \alpha , t ) = 0\). Taking the same case as defined, let \(\kappa _{0} ( \alpha , t ) = \alpha \) and \(\kappa _{1} ( \alpha , t ) = 1  \alpha \), so Eq. (4) becomes
Applying the above expansion on system (1), we get the following expression of the governing model:
with initial conditions being the same as defined in Eq. (2). Since model (6) is equivalent to Eq. (1) and is computationally easy to discuss, further dynamic analysis is carried out using model (6) to attain effective solutions. Subsequently, the following theorems elucidate the existence and uniqueness of the solutions for system (6), which expands the validity of the governing model mathematically.
Theorem 2.1
Let \(\Lambda \in \Re _{ +}^{7}\) be the set of all possible solutions of system (6), then it is a uniformly bounded subset of \(\Re _{ +}^{7}\) such that
Proof
Utilizing expansion (5) on Eq. (3), we get the expression
On simplifying by substituting values from system (6) and taking \(\eta ^{ *} \) as a total proportion of natural deaths defined as
since \(0 < \alpha \le 1\), therefore Eq. (8) can be converted into
As \(0 < \frac{S ( t )}{k} \le 1\), so the above inequality reduces to
On integrating, we get
Therefore, as \(t \to \infty \), we obtain the final statement of boundedness as follows:
□
Theorem 2.2
Assume \(\Omega ( \mathrm{M} ( t ) ):\Re _{ +}^{7} \to \Re _{ +}^{7}\) to be the matrix of the righthand side of system (6) such that \(\Omega ( \mathrm{M} ( t ) )\) and \(\frac{\partial \Omega ( \mathrm{M} ( t ) )}{\partial \mathrm{M} ( t )}\) are continuous and
Then, for given initial conditions (2), there exists a unique, nonnegative, and bounded solution of system (6) for all \(t \in [  \tau ,\infty )\).
Proof
Boundedness of system (6) can be followed from Theorem 2.1. Here, the remaining elements of the above statement are proved. Consider
where
and
Equation (17) can be further expanded into
such that
and
where
Equation (18) can be manipulated as follows:
Let \(\delta = \Vert \mathrm{A}_{1} \Vert + \Vert \mathrm{A}_{2} \Vert + \Vert \mathrm{A}_{3} \Vert \), so the required statement for uniqueness is achieved as
where \(\tilde{\alpha } = \vert ( \frac{1}{\alpha }  1 ) \vert \) for \(0 < \alpha \le 1\). Next, to prove the nonnegativity of the solutions, we use the positivity of initial conditions (2), i.e., \(\xi _{i} ( \vartheta ) \ge 0\) and \(\xi _{i} ( 0 ) > 0\) for \(i = 1,2, \ldots ,7\). Consider the first equation of system (6), it can be deduced to
On manipulating, we get
Since \(0 \le e^{  ( ( \mu + \eta _{S} + ( 1  \alpha ) )/\alpha )t} \le 1\) for \(t > 0\), therefore, Eq. (19) reduces to \(S ( t ) \ge 0\).
Thus, the nonnegativity of \(S ( t )\) is proved. Analogously, all the remaining equations of system (6) can be ascertained to have nonnegative solutions with the assumption of positive initial conditions. □
3 Basic reproduction number
The basic reproduction number, mostly denoted by \(R_{0}\), has a significant importance in epidemiological studies as it measures the expected number of secondary cases produced by the contact of a single infected individual in a completely susceptible population. If \(R_{0} < 1\), then the disease dies out after a time period, whereas if \(R_{0} > 1\), then the disease spreads out and becomes endemic. It is dimensionless and can be calculated either directly by the product of transmissibility, average rate of contact, and duration of infectiousness or by using the next generation method [25, 26].
Here, using the next generation method, a submodel of SVELITR model (6) is considered to only contain the infectious compartments. Therefore, for the case of model (6), it includes the exposed, latent, and infected individuals, i.e., the equations of E, L, and I. Let
where \overrightarrow{X}={[\begin{array}{ccc}E& L& I\end{array}]}^{t} and F(\overrightarrow{X})={[\begin{array}{ccc}\beta SI/\alpha & 0& 0\end{array}]}^{t} define new infections entering each compartment. Since no new infected individual enters L and I compartments directly, rather they transit from the E compartment into L and then I compartments, therefore, the second and third element of \(F ( \vec{X} )\) are zero. On the other hand, \(V ( \vec{X} )\) can be further fragmented down as
where \(V^{ } ( \vec{X} )\) and \(V^{ +} ( \vec{X} )\) contain all other outputs and inputs of each E, L, and I compartments, respectively. Hence \(V ( \vec{X} )\) can be outlined as follows:
Taking Jacobian matrix of Eq. (20) at a diseasefree equilibrium point
we get
From Eq. (21), we can extract the following next generation matrix:
On calculating the eigenvalues of Eq. (22), the eigenvalue with the largest magnitude is the required value of the basic reproduction number. So, after some simplification, we get
4 System dynamics
In this section, the equilibria of system (6) along with its dynamic properties are discussed in particular. Let the Jacobian matrix at an equilibrium point \(( \hat{S},\hat{V},\hat{E},\hat{L},\hat{I},\hat{T}_{r},\hat{R} )\) be outlined as {\mathbf{J}}_{(\stackrel{\u02c6}{S},\stackrel{\u02c6}{V},\stackrel{\u02c6}{E},\stackrel{\u02c6}{L},\stackrel{\u02c6}{I},{\stackrel{\u02c6}{T}}_{r},\stackrel{\u02c6}{R})}=\left[\begin{array}{cc}{M}_{1}& {M}_{2}\\ {M}_{3}& {M}_{4}\end{array}\right], where
and
So, the corresponding characteristic equation for the eigenvalues λ can be articulated as
Theorem 4.1
The trivial equilibrium solution, \(\Lambda _{0} ( 0,0,0,0,0,0,0 ) \in \Re _{ +}^{7}\), of system (6) is asymptotically unstable for all \(0 \le \tau < \infty \) and \(0 < \alpha \le 1\).
Proof
It can be easily proved by eigenvalues of J, i.e., for all \(0 \le \tau < \infty \),
Since \(r > 1 + \eta _{S} + \mu  \alpha \), it is clear that \(\lambda _{7} > 0\) for \(0 < \alpha \le 1\). Thus, \(\Lambda _{0} \in \Re _{ +}^{7}\) is unstable for all \(0 \le \tau < \infty \). □
Theorem 4.2
The diseasefree equilibrium solution
of system (6), for \(r > 1 + \eta _{S} + \mu  \alpha \), is locally asymptotically stable if \(R_{0} < 1\) and unstable when \(R_{0} > 1\) for all \(0 \le \tau < \infty \).
Proof
Solving J for the equilibrium point
we get the negative real eigenvalues
with the transcendental equation
where
From the Routh–Hurwitz condition [27] for cubic polynomial, if \(C_{2} > 0\), \(C_{0} ( 1  e^{  2\lambda \tau } R_{0} ) > 0\) and \(C_{1}C_{2} > C_{0} ( 1  e^{  2\lambda \tau } R_{0} )\), then \(Q ( \lambda ) > 0\) for all nonnegative real eigenvalues, and thus all the real parts of the eigenvalues must be negative. Therefore, it can be clearly seen that \(C_{1} > 0\), \(C_{2} > 0\), and \(C_{0} > 0\), so the only thing left to be proved is that \(( 1  e^{  2\lambda \tau } R_{0} ) > 0\). Accordingly, when \(\tau = 0\), the only possibility for \(( 1  e^{  2\lambda \tau } R_{0} ) > 0\) is that \(R_{0} < 1\). Hence, \(\Lambda _{1} \in \Re _{ +}^{7}\) is asymptotically stable if \(R_{0} < 1\) for \(\tau = 0\). If \(R_{0} > 1\) and \(( 1  e^{  2\lambda \tau } R_{0} ) < 0\) implies \(Q ( 0 ) < 0\), then Eq. (25) must have a nonnegative real part, thus it becomes unstable.
Now, \(\forall \tau \in \Re _{ +} \), we prove that if \(\lambda = a \pm ib\) is the complex solution of \(Q ( \lambda )\), then \(\Lambda _{1} \in \Re _{ +}^{7}\) is stable if \(a \le 0\). On substituting the complex value of λ, for \(a \ge 0\) and \(b^{2} > 0\), into Eq. (21) and separating the real and imaginary parts, we get the following polynomial:
\(( C_{0} + a ( C_{1} + a ( a + C_{2} ) ) )^{2} > C_{0}^{2} e^{  4a\tau } R_{0}^{2}\), whenever \(R_{0} < 1\), \(\forall \tau \in \Re _{ +} \) since there is no solution for \(a \ge 0\) and \(b^{2} > 0\), thus there is no complex number with a nonnegative real part. Hence, \(\Lambda _{1} \in \Re _{ +}^{7}\) is asymptotically stable when \(R_{0} < 1\) and unstable when \(R_{0} > 1\), \(\forall \tau \in \Re _{ +} \). □
Theorem 4.3
If \(R_{0} > 1\), then the endemic equilibrium \(\Lambda _{2} ( \breve{S},\breve{V},\breve{E},\breve{L},\breve{I},\breve{T}_{r},\breve{R} ) \in \Re _{ +}^{7}\) is locally asymptotically stable and unstable if and only if either it has a zero solution or has a complex conjugate pair of purely imaginary solutions when \(R_{0} > 1\) for some \(\tau > \tau _{0}\).
Proof
Solving J for the equilibrium point \(\Lambda _{2} ( \breve{S},\breve{V},\breve{E},\breve{L},\breve{I},\breve{T}_{r},\breve{R} ) \in \Re _{ +}^{7}\), we get the negative real eigenvalues
with the transcendental equation
where
such that
For \(\tau = 0\), \(Q ( \lambda )\) reduces into
such that \(U_{3} > 0\), \(U_{2} > 0\), \(( U_{1}  C_{0} ) =  \frac{C_{1} U_{b}}{\alpha } > 0\), and \(( U_{0} + U_{a} ) =  \frac{C_{0}U_{b}}{\alpha ^{3}} ( \alpha ^{2} + R_{0}  2 ) > 0\) as \(R_{0} > 1\) and \(U_{b} < 0\). It can be easily manipulated and investigated that Eq. (28) satisfies the Routh–Hurwitz condition of fourth order polynomial, i.e., in addition to the above inequalities, \(U_{3}U_{2} > ( U_{1}  C_{0} )\) and \(U_{1}U_{2}U_{3} > ( U_{0} + U_{a} )U_{3}^{2} + ( U_{1}  C_{0} )^{2}\). Thus \(Q ( \lambda ) > 0\), therefore when \(R_{0} > 1\), all the real parts of the eigenvalues are negative for \(\tau = 0\). Next, it is also clear from Eq. (27) that \(Q ( 0 ) = U_{0} + U_{a} \ne 0\), so the only possibility of \(\Lambda _{2} \in \Re _{ +}^{7}\) to be unstable is that a complex conjugate pair of purely imaginary solution exists for some critical value \(\tau _{0} > 0\). Now consider \(\lambda = \pm ib\), and on substituting in Eq. (27) and separating real and imaginary parts, we get
and
On simplifying and assuming \(\varpi = b^{2}\), we get
where \(v_{3} =  2U_{2} + U_{3}^{2}\), \(v_{2} = 2U_{0} + U_{2}^{2}  2U_{1}U_{3}\), \(v_{1} =  C_{0}^{2} + U_{1}^{2}  2U_{0}U_{2}\), \(v_{0} = U_{0}^{2}  U_{a}^{2}\). The existence of at least one positive real root will lead Eq. (31) to a complex conjugate pair of purely imaginary solutions and also a Hopf bifurcation might exist. Since it is straightforward from the constant of Eq. (31) that \(v_{0} < 0\), when \(R_{0} > 1\) and \(\lim_{\varpi \to \infty } Y ( \varpi ) = + \infty \), therefore \(Y ( \varpi )\) must have at least one positive real root. Hence, Eq. (27) produces a complex conjugate pair of purely imaginary solutions for some \(\tau _{0} > 0\) and \(\Lambda _{2} \in \Re _{ +}^{7}\) becomes unstable when \(R_{0} > 1\). □
5 Existence of Hopf bifurcation
From Theorem 4.3, the endemic equilibrium point is unstable if and only if \(Q ( \lambda ) = 0\) of Eq. (27) produces a complex conjugate pair of purely imaginary solutions for some \(\tau _{0} > 0\), which might lead to the existence of the Hopf bifurcation [11]. As it is possible that Eq. (31) can have four positive real roots, i.e., \(\varpi _{p}\) for \(p = 1,2,3,4\), thus there are four purely imaginary pairs of eigenvalues \(\lambda _{p} = ib_{p} = \pm i\sqrt{\varpi _{p}}\) for \(p = 1,2,3,4\). Now, we may find values of the time delay \(\tau _{p}\) corresponding to the value of \(b_{p}\). By substituting \(b_{p}\) into Eqs. (29)–(30) and solving for \(\tau _{p}\), we get
Thus,
The minimum time delay at which purely imaginary eigenvalues \(\lambda _{0} = ib_{0}\) occur is
Now, for the transversality condition for the existence of Hopf bifurcation, we have to prove \(\frac{d}{d\tau } \operatorname{Re} ( \lambda ) \vert _{\tau = \tau _{0}} \ne 0\). So, taking the derivative of Eq. (27) and simplifying yields
with \(\lambda _{0} = ib_{0}\), we get
where
Since \(\operatorname{Re} ( \frac{d\lambda }{d\tau } )^{  1} \vert _{\tau = \tau _{0}} \ne 0\), thus \(\frac{d}{d\tau } \operatorname{Re} ( \lambda ) \vert _{\tau = \tau _{0}} \ne 0\), with the critical point \(\tau _{0}\) as a Hopf bifurcation point.
6 Numerical findings
In this section, numerical investigations of system (6) are carried out by considering some numerical values of the parameters, as shown in the form of three sets in Table 2. Taking the initial conditions as
for \(\vartheta \in [  \tau ,0 )\), all the manipulation and plotting of the dynamics are undergone by using Mathematica 10.0. Stability of the equilibrium states and phase portraits is discussed in detail through graphs and tables.
On using set 1 of Table 2, the basic reproduction numbers \(R_{0}\) and constant solutions of \(S ( t )\), \(V ( t )\), \(E ( t )\), \(L ( t )\), \(I ( t )\), \(T_{r} ( t )\), and \(R ( t )\) for different values of α are calculated and represented in Table 3. Since at each value of α, \(R_{0} < 1\), therefore the plots obtained for some values of \(\alpha = 0.8, 0.95\) and 1, \(\tau = 1\) and \(t \in [ 0, 200 ]\) in Fig. 2, verify the stability of diseasefree equilibrium states for \(R_{0} = 0.37668, 0.545976, 0.62441\), respectively.
Subsequently, for the values of parameters in set 2 of Table 2, the basic reproduction number along with the constant solutions of \(S ( t )\), \(V ( t )\), \(E ( t )\), \(L ( t )\), \(I ( t )\), \(T_{r} ( t )\), and \(R ( t )\) for different values of α are obtained and represented in Table 4. As at these values \(R_{0} > 1\) for all \(0 < \alpha \le 1\), then, according to Theorems 4.2 and 4.3, the diseasefree equilibrium state becomes unstable. On the other hand, endemic equilibrium will become stable for some \(\tau < \tau _{0}\). Therefore, calculating the critical Hopf bifurcation point \(\tau _{0}\) by using Eq. (32), we have \(\tau _{0} = 0.380397\) for the values of parameters in set 2 of Table 2. Consequently, the plots of system (6) in Fig. 3 at different values of \(\alpha = 0.8, 0.95, 1\) and \(t \in [ 0, 200 ]\), the stability of endemic equilibrium state is evident due the reason that \(\tau = 0.035 < \tau _{0}\) with \(R_{0} = 2.58500, 3.95079, 4.62122\); whereas Fig. 4 shows unstability of the endemic equilibrium states for the same values of all parameters and \(R_{0}\) due to the reason that \(\tau = 0.9 > \tau _{0}\). In addition, the phase diagrams are also portrayed in Figs. 5 and 6, at \(\tau = 1.5\) and \(\tau = 3\), by using values of set 2 in Table 2, for \(\alpha = 0.8, 0.95, 1\), and \(t \in [ 0, 5000 ]\). These figures further illustrate that as the values of τ and α are increased system (6) loses stability and generates the limit cyclic patterns of the infectious compartments, i.e., \(E ( t )\), \(L ( t )\), and \(I ( t )\).
The abovementioned graphical and tabulated results are successfully attained at different values of fractional order α, which greatly enables us to illustrate the equilibrium states and the basic reproduction number \(R_{0}\) of system (6) with memory effect. Tables 3 and 4 significantly elaborate the effect of α on \(R_{0}\), through which it can be clearly seen in detail that within the time bar a fractional variation in the system changes the value of the basic reproductive number.
7 Conclusions
A system of seven fractional order differential equations was designed with time delay to illustrate the seven epidemiological compartments. These compartments elaborated each stage of any individual from being susceptible and exposed to infection till its treatment and recovery or being vaccinated and safe. In addition, time delay was also added in the treatment compartment to show the dynamics of the individuals of exposed, latent, or infected stages going through the treatment with different rates and being recovered later. Moreover, we applied a special case of the proportional fractional derivative on the system of equations. This simplified form made it computationally easy to discuss the variations and equilibrium states of the functions by converting the system into an integer order without losing the originality of the fractional index. This definition also enabled to study the significant impact of the fractional index change on the basic reproduction number and the stability of the equilibrium states. Furthermore, the pointtopoint outcomes of the study can be summarized as follows:

The basic reproduction number \(R_{0}\) does not remain constant throughout the dynamic process of an epidemic in a particular time interval, but a fractional index variation in the system will also cause change in its value within the time interval.

For any delay in time taken by an individual for the treatment and recovery, if the basic reproduction number of the infection for each fractional index step is less than 1, then a diseasefree state can be achieved.

If \(R_{0} > 1\) for each fractional index value and time delay by an individual is less than the Hopf bifurcation point, then the infection becomes endemic with a constant rate.

If \(R_{0} > 1\) for each fractional value and time delay by an individual is greater than the Hopf bifurcation point, then the system moves towards an unstability state bit by bit, and so the infection outbreaks.
As the proposed epidemiological model for the transmission of an infection that shows the impact of fractional operator on the basic reproduction number of any infection has not been found in the literature yet, it will be greatly advantageous for the epidemiologist to cope with the infection at each fractional index value before the occurrence of a complete change. In future, we will design a model that will demonstrate the age classification and impact of fractional index variation of an infection on different age groups.
Availability of data and materials
Not applicable.
References
Khan, A., Hassan, M., Imran, M.: Estimating the basic reproduction number for singlestrain Dengue fever epidemics. Infect. Dis. Poverty 3(1), 12 (2014)
Haq, F., et al.: Numerical analysis of fractional order epidemic model of childhood diseases. Discrete Dyn. Nat. Soc. 2017, Article ID 4057089 (2017)
Blackwood, J.C., Childs, L.M.: An introduction to compartmental modeling for the budding infectious disease modeler. Lett. Biomath. 5(1), 195–221 (2018)
Kandhway, K., Kuri, J.: How to run a campaign: optimal control of SIS and SIR information epidemics. Appl. Math. Comput. 231, 79–92 (2014)
Moore, H.C., et al.: Modelling the seasonal epidemics of respiratory syncytial virus in young children. PLoS ONE 9(6), e100422 (2014)
Yin, Z., Yu, Y., Lu, Z.: Stability analysis of an agestructured SEIRS model with time delay. Mathematics 8(3), 455 (2020)
Zhang, Z., Yang, F., Xia, W.: Influence of time delay on bifurcation of a synthetic drug transmission model with psychological addicts. Adv. Differ. Equ. 2020(1), 1 (2020)
Liu, L., Wang, Y.: Stability analysis for a delayed SIR model with a nonlinear incidence rate. J. Nonlinear Sci. Appl. 10(11), 5834–5845 (2017)
Rifhat, R., Teng, Z., Wang, C.: Extinction and persistence of a stochastic SIRV epidemic model with nonlinear incidence rate. Adv. Differ. Equ. 2021(1), 200 (2021)
Ameen, I., Baleanu, D., Ali, H.M.: An efficient algorithm for solving the fractional optimal control of SIRV epidemic model with a combination of vaccination and treatment. Chaos Solitons Fractals 137, 109892 (2020)
Sirijampa, A., Chinviriyasit, S., Chinviriyasit, W.: Hopf bifurcation analysis of a delayed SEIR epidemic model with infectious force in latent and infected period. Adv. Differ. Equ. 2018(1), 348 (2018)
Rong, X., et al.: Effect of delay in diagnosis on transmission of COVID19. Math. Biosci. Eng. 17(3), 2725–2740 (2020)
Rihan, F.A., Anwar, M.N.: Qualitative analysis of delayed SIR epidemic model with a saturated incidence rate. Int. J. Differ. Equ. 2012, Article ID 408637 (2012)
Elazzouzi, A., et al.: Global stability analysis for a generalized delayed SIR model with vaccination and treatment. Adv. Differ. Equ. 2019(1), 532 (2019)
Nakata, Y., Omori, R.: Delay equation formulation for an epidemic model with waning immunity: an application to mycoplasma pneumoniae. IFACPapersOnLine 48(18), 132–135 (2015)
Diethelm, K., Ford, N.J.: Analysis of fractional differential equations. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 265(2), 229–248 (2002)
Khan, N.A., Hameed, T., Razzaq, O.A.: Modelling and simulation of coal gases in a nanoporous medium: a biologically inspired stochastic simulation. Soft Comput. 24, 5133–5150 (2020)
Khan, N., Razzaq, O., Ayaz, M.: Some properties and applications of conformable fractional Laplace transform (CFLT). J. Fract. Calc. Appl. 9(1), 72–81 (2018)
Jarad, F., Abdeljawad, T., Alzabut, J.: Generalized fractional derivatives generated by a class of local proportional derivatives. Eur. Phys. J. Spec. Top. 226(16), 3457–3471 (2017)
Khan, N.A., Razzaq, O.A., Ara, A., Riaz, F.: Numerical solution of system of fractional differential equations in imprecise environment. In: Numerical Simulation – From Brain Imaging Turbulent Flows, pp. 167–186 (2016)
Anderson, D.R., Ulness, D.J.: Newly defined conformable derivatives. Adv. Dyn. Syst. Appl. 10(2), 109–137 (2015)
Razzaq, O.A., et al.: Optimal surveillance mitigation of COVID’19 disease outbreak: fractional order optimal control of compartment model. Results Phys. 20, 103715 (2021)
Jarad, F., Alqudah, M.A., Abdeljawad, T.: On more general forms of proportional fractional operators. Open Math. 18(1), 167–176 (2020)
Abdeljawad, T., et al.: More properties of fractional proportional differences. J. Math. Anal. Model. 2(1), 72–90 (2021)
Van den Driessche, P., Watmough, J.: Reproduction numbers and subthreshold endemic equilibria for compartmental models of disease transmission. Math. Biosci. 180(1), 29–48 (2002)
AlSheikh, S.A.: Modeling and analysis of an SEIR epidemic model with a limited resource for treatment. Glob. J. Sci. Front. Res. Math. Decis. Sci. 12(14), 56–66 (2012)
Ahmed, E., ElSayed, A., ElSaka, H.A.: On some Routh–Hurwitz conditions for fractional order differential equations and their applications in Lorenz, Rössler, Chua and Chen systems. Phys. Lett. A 358(1), 1–4 (2006)
Acknowledgements
This project was funded by the research and development office (RDO) at the ministry of Education, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, grant No. (HIQI242019). The authors also acknowledge with thanks the research and development office (RDOKAU) at KingAbdulaziz University for technical support.
Funding
Research and development office (RDO) at the ministry of Education, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, grant No. (HIQI242019).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
All authors carried out the proofs and conceived of the study. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This article does not contain any studies with human participants or animals performed by any of the authors.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Alzahrani, A.K., Razzaq, O.A., Khan, N.A. et al. Transmissibility of epidemic diseases caused by delay with local proportional fractional derivative. Adv Differ Equ 2021, 292 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13662021034354
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13662021034354
Keywords
 Proportional fractional derivative
 Hopf bifurcation
 Stability
 Limit cycles