 Research
 Open access
 Published:
Complex mathematical SIR model for spreading of COVID19 virus with MittagLeffler kernel
Advances in Difference Equations volume 2021, Article number: 319 (2021)
Abstract
This paper investigates a new model on coronavirus19 disease (COVID19), that is complex fractional SIR epidemic model with a nonstandard nonlinear incidence rate and a recovery, where derivative operator with MittagLeffler kernel in the Caputo sense (ABC). The model has two equilibrium points when the basic reproduction number \(R_{0} > 1\); a diseasefree equilibrium \(E_{0}\) and a disease endemic equilibrium \(E_{1}\). The diseasefree equilibrium stage is locally and globally asymptotically stable when the basic reproduction number \(R_{0} <1\), we show that the endemic equilibrium state is locally asymptotically stable if \(R_{0} > 1\). We also prove the existence and uniqueness of the solution for the Atangana–Baleanu SIR model by using a fixedpoint method. Since the Atangana–Baleanu fractional derivative gives better precise results to the derivative with exponential kernel because of having fractional order, hence, it is a generalized form of the derivative with exponential kernel. The numerical simulations are explored for various values of the fractional order. Finally, the effect of the ABC fractionalorder derivative on suspected and infected individuals carefully is examined and compared with the real data.
1 Introduction
The coronavirus is a new viral pneumonia, deadly and rapidly spreading infection that has put great panic around the globe since the break out late 2019. Within a short span of time, it affected every country all over the world, which urges every nation take severe action to control the wild spread of the virus as the severity of the disease will harm human life badly.
It is well known that infectious diseases are a massive threat for humans and also for national economies. Proper understanding of a disease dynamics is necessary, which plays a major role for controlling and eventually exterminate the infection in a community. Implementation of the correct applicable strategy against the disease transmission is another challenge. Mathematical modeling of the infectious diseases is one of the key tools in order to handle these challenges. A number of disease models have been established in the past, which enables us to investigate and control the spread of infectious diseases in a better way [1–3].
Regarding COVID19, from the initial spread of COVID19, many of the known mathematical models were used, or newly established by many researchers, For example Giordano et al. in [4] proposed the so called SIDARTHE model and concluded that restrictive socialdistancing measures will need to be combined with widespread testing and contact tracing to end the ongoing COVID19 pandemic. At a same time, Alshammari [5] proposed the SEYNHR compartmental model and applied real data for Saudi Arabia and obtained good predictions on a short term. The role of quarantining and isolation to control the spread of COVID19 is studied by Memon et al. [6], where they used an extended SIR model. They show that quarantine and isolation are effective measures to control the outbreak.
From real data of the infectious disease, we know that the outbreak of the disease within the country or state for time is generally nonlinear, which tells us to design the system where we can study those dynamic nonlinear phenomena. By this system, we can be able to define the transmission of such a contagious disease, which helps us to interpret the remedial measures to stop or contain the spread of the contagious disease.
Most of the present day studies on mathematical modeling of infectious disease are based on integerorder differential equations (IDEs). However, more recently, many authors state that fractionalorder models (FDEs) can describe natural phenomena more precisely than the integerorder differential equations because fractionalorder derivatives and integrals describe the memory and hereditary properties of different phenomena [7]. Further, the classical IDEs cannot provide the result for noninteger values. In order to overcome the above limitation of integerorder derivatives, different types of fractionalorder operators were defined, some of the research can be found in the existing literature [8] and applications of these fractionalorder operators are noted in [9], also Sene in [10, 11] consider the Liu et al. [12] chaotic system with Caputo fractional derivative and show the Lyapunov exponent to characterize the nature of chaos and prove the dissipativity of the considered chaotic system.
However, it is known that the classical form of the fractional derivatives with singular kernel may not be suitable to characterize the nonlocal dynamics in an appropriate manner. In order to overcome this problem, Atangana and Baleanu [13] establish a new model, the so called generalized ABC differential operator involving the MittagLeffler (ML) and nonlocal type kernel, which has an antiderivative fractional integral operator [14]. This new definition of derivative is shown to be more efficient for the SIR model with generalized incidence rate compared to the other existing fractional models [15] and an exothermic reactions model having a constant heat source in porous media with power problem [16]. More recently, Atangana and Atangana [17] solved the system of ABC fractional partial differential equations to see the side effects of facemasks, which is necessary to protect from COVID19 and concluded that appropriate facemasks that could help avoid reinhaling enough CO_{2} should be used every time one is in open air even when alone especially in a windy environment. Later, Khan et al. [18] explored the dynamics of COVID19 with quarantine and isolations with real statistical cases reported in the mainland China, where the model is developed by using a fractalfractional derivative in the Atangana–Baleanu sense. They indicate that their results are useful in the early eradication of the disease in the community. Similarly, Sane in [19] also consider the SIR epidemic model with MittagLeffler fractional derivative and delay, he uses a Lyapunov direct method and analyzes the global asymptotic stability of the diseasefree equilibrium and the endemic equilibrium. Naik et al. [20] proposed an Atangana–Baleanu–Caputo operator for the transmission of COVID19 epidemic, where they used real data from Pakistan. They show that fractional operators have many advantages over the existing nonintegerorder types.
The studies from [13] to [20] provide us with enough motivation to study and analyze a new fractional SIR model involving the ABC operator with complete memory effects. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time to study a nonlocal and nonsingular derivative operator for the model of the SIR, which has nonlinear incidence and recovery rates, where we also examine the existence and uniqueness results with the Atangana–Baleanu derivative by using a fixedpoint method.
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. Some preliminary results are given in Sect. 2. Section 3 is devoted to the new fractional SIR model and its main characteristics. We first derived the solution of the problem and then provided the existence and uniqueness result results in Sect. 4. In the last section, we demonstrate the numerical solutions for Eq. (10) by using the ABCderivative in a graphical method. We also discussed the necessity of maintaining enough number of hospital beds for controlling of the infectious diseases.
2 Preliminary results
We note some background material for the Caputo and Atangana–Baleanu fractional derivatives and Laplace transform are presented [13, 21–23], which we use later.
Definition 2.1
MittagLeffler function is defined as
Definition 2.2
Let \(f\in C^{n}\) be a function, then the fractional Caputo derivative of order α is defined as [13]
where \(\alpha \in ( n1,n )\) and \(n\in\mathbb{ N}\). Obviously, as \(\alpha \rightarrow 1\), \({}_{0}^{C} D_{t}^{\alpha } ( f ( t ) ) \) tends to the \(f' ( t )\).
Definition 2.3
Let \(f\in H^{1} ( b, b_{1} )\), \(\alpha \in ( 0, 1 ] \), then the Atangana–Beleanu–Caputo (ABC) derivative is defined as [13]
where the term \(B ( \alpha )\) is the normalization function with \(B ( 0 ) =B ( 1 ) =1\). The associated fractional integral is given by
If \(\alpha =0\), the initial function is recovered in Eq. (3), we have the ordinary integral for \(\alpha =1\).
Proposition 2.1
If \(0<\alpha <1\), we have
Theorem 2.1
The Laplace transform of fractional Caputo derivative and Atangana–Beleanu–Caputo (ABC) derivatives is given by
and
Property 2.1
The inverse Laplace transform of specific functions can be obtained:
3 Mathematical model and discussion
Let us consider the total population \(N ( t )\) to consist of three subcategories: susceptible \(S ( t )\), infected \(I ( t )\) and recovered \(R ( t )\) individuals \(( SIR )\), where \(N ( t ) =S ( t ) +I ( t ) +R ( t )\) as seen in Fig. 1. There are many factors involved in modeling the infectious diseases and these factors substantially affect the dynamical behavior of the models such as incident rate and recovery rate. In the classical SIR model, incident rate \(\beta \frac{S ( t ) I ( t )}{N ( t )}\) and linear recovery rate \(\mu I ( t )\) are used. However, as for COVID19, many infectious diseases show multiple peaks or periodic oscillations during the outbreak or in progress. Therefore, several nonlinear incidence rates have been suggested since they can produce rich dynamics for the epidemic models [24, 25]. Liu et al. [26] proposed the following form of nonlinear saturated incidence rate to include the effect of behavioral changes:
where \(\beta ^{*},l,h, k^{*} >0\). This model is due to Ruan et al. [27, 28]. More recently, a more general form was considered by Rao et al. [29].
On the other hand, in view of the diversity of public resources, it is not enough to study the effect of treatment capacity on a large scale at this time, if we want to further explore the influence of hospital bed number on disease transmission. Then we need to define the nonlinear recovery rate introduced by [30]
where \(\alpha _{1}\) is the maximum per capita recovery rate, when health care resources suffice and there are few infectious individuals, \(\alpha _{0}\) is the minimum per capita recovery rate due to lack of clinical resources, b is the ratio between the number of hospital bed and the population, all the above parameters are nonnegative. It has the following properties: (i) \(\frac{\partial \Pi ( I,b )}{\partial I} <0, \lim_{I\rightarrow \infty } \Pi ( I,b ) = \alpha _{0}\) and \(\lim_{I\rightarrow 0} \Pi ( I,b ) = \alpha _{1}\), i.e., \(\Pi ( I,b )\) is a decreasing function of I. (ii) \(\frac{\partial \Pi ( I,b )}{\partial b} >0, \lim_{b\rightarrow \infty } \Pi ( I,b ) = \alpha _{1}\) and \(\lim_{b\rightarrow 0} \Pi ( I,b ) = \alpha _{0}\), i.e., \(\Pi ( I,b )\) is an increasing function of b.
Here, we assume individuals move from compartment S to I with transmission rates \(\frac{\beta IS}{k+I} ( l=h=1\text{ in Eq. } ( 9 ) )\), and when an individual is infected, then the individual either recovers at a rate \(\Pi ( I,b ) = ( \alpha _{0} + ( \alpha _{1}  \alpha _{0} ) \frac{b}{b+I} )\) or dies at the rate of γI. Then this complex SIR model can be represented by following nonlinear system of equations:
where \(A=n\times N, N\) refer to total number of people and n is the birth rate, μ is a positive constant representing the natural death of the population, γ is a positive constant representing the disease induced death rate, \(\alpha _{0}\) is the minimum per capita recovery rate due to the function of basic clinical resources and \(\alpha _{1}\) is the maximum per capita recovery rate due to the sufficient health care resource and few infectious individuals as well as the inherent property of a specific disease.
The model in (11) is not capable of representing the influence of memory effects with respect to time derivative. In order to account for the memory effect, in addition, we modify the fractional operator by an auxiliary parameter σ, having the dimension of second, to ensure that the right and lefthand sides of the resultant equation possess the same dimension \(s^{1}\). Consequently, we can reformulate the system in (9) by using the ABC derivatives as
where \(0<\alpha <1 \). In the first two equations in (12), \(R ( t )\) does not appear, it is therefore assumed the first two equations are sufficient to handle the full system. We modify the fractional operator by an auxiliary parameter σ, having the dimension of day, to ensure that the right and lefthand sides of the resultant equation possess the same dimension \(s^{1}\)
3.1 Nonnegative solution
In this section, we show that the feasibility region of the system (12) is given by the closed set
which is positively invariant.
Lemma 3.1
The closed set defined in (13) is positively invariant with respect to the fractional model (12).
Proof
Adding all three equations in (12), we have
Applying the Laplace transform on both sides, we obtain
Using Theorem 2.1 and the properties of the Laplace transform, we got
Hence
now, applying the inverse Laplace transform and using Property 2.1, we find
where \(m= \frac{\alpha \hat{\mu }}{ ( B ( \alpha ) + \hat{\mu } ( 1\alpha ) )}\), since the MittagLeffler function has an asymptotic behavior, we obtain \(N ( t ) \leq \frac{\hat{A}}{\hat{\mu }} = \frac{A}{\mu } \) as \(t\rightarrow \infty \). Hence, a solution of the fractional model (12) stays in Ω for every \(t>0\). Consequently, the closed set is a positively invariant set regarding the fractional model (12). □
3.2 Equilibrium points, basic reproduction number and local stability of equilibrium points
The equilibrium points of the system are the zeros of second side of Eq. (12), obviously, diseasefree equilibrium point i.e., \(I=0\) and \(S=A/\mu \) or \(E_{0} = ( \frac{A}{\mu },0 )\). Therefore, the model (12) has a threshold parameter \(R_{0}\), known as the basic reproduction number, this is defined as the number of secondary infections produced by a single infection in a completely susceptible population. It is not difficult to write the reproduction number for the diseasefree equilibrium point of Eq. (12) as [5]
The existence of the endemic equilibrium point(s) can be determined by the relation
where \(I^{*}\) is the solution of the following equation:
Here, the coefficients are given by
The solution of quadratic equation in (21) is given by
Then we have the three cases of \(R_{0}\)
 ∗:

If \(R_{0} <1\), so, \(A_{1}\) and \(A_{3} >0\), if \(b\geq \frac{\mu ( \alpha _{1}  \alpha _{0} )}{b ( \beta + \frac{\mu }{k} ) ( \alpha _{1} +\gamma +\mu ) ( 1+\mu ) ( 1 R_{0} )}\) no endemic equilibrium, if \(b< \frac{\mu ( \alpha _{1}  \alpha _{0} )}{b ( \beta + \frac{\mu }{k} ) ( \alpha _{1} +\gamma +\mu ) ( 1+\mu ) ( 1 R_{0} )}\), we have no endemic equilibrium for \(A_{2}^{2} 4 A_{1} A_{3} <0\), one positive endemic equilibrium for \(A_{2}^{2} 4 A_{1} A_{3} =0\) and two endemic equilibrium points for \(A_{2}^{2} 4 A_{1} A_{3} >0\).
 ∗:

If \(R_{0} =1\), then, if \(b< \frac{\mu ( \alpha _{1}  \alpha _{0} )}{b ( \beta + \frac{\mu }{k} ) ( \alpha _{1} +\gamma +\mu ) ( 1+\mu ) ( 1 R_{0} )}\), then system unique endemic equilibrium point.
 ∗:

If \(R_{0} >1\), then, if \(b< \frac{\mu ( \alpha _{1}  \alpha _{0} )}{b ( \beta + \frac{\mu }{k} ) ( \alpha _{1} +\gamma +\mu ) ( 1+\mu ) ( 1 R_{0} )}\), then system unique endemic equilibrium point.
Theorem 3.1
The diseasefree equilibrium point \(\mathrm{E}_{0}\) is locally asymptotically stable and if \(\mathrm{R}_{0} <1\) then it is unstable if \(\mathrm{R}_{0} >1\).
Proof
The jacobian matrix corresponding to system (12) is
Then the solution of characteristic equation associated to \(J ( \frac{A}{\mu },0 )\) is given by
Hence, if \(R_{0} <1\), the diseasefree equilibrium point \(\mathrm{E}_{0}\) is locally asymptotically stable, if \(\mathrm{R}_{0} >1\), it is unstable. □
Theorem 3.2
A sufficient condition for the endemic equilibrium \(E_{1} = ( S^{*}, I^{*} )\) to be locally asymptotically stable is \(N_{1} <0\) and \(N_{2} >0\), where
Proof
See the book of Chou and Friedman [31], we here note that
Therefore, local asymptotic stability of the endemic equilibrium point is a function of \(R_{0}\) and the number of available hospital beds \(( b )\). □
Theorem 3.3
For the system (12), if \(R_{0} <1\), i.e. \(\beta A< k\mu ( \alpha _{1} +\gamma +\mu )\), the diseasefree equilibrium \(E_{0} = ( \frac{A}{\mu },0 )\) is globally asymptotically stable.
Proof
Consider the Lyapunov function \(V ( t ) =I\) in \(R^{2+}\), Calculating the time fractional derivative of the \(V ( t )\), we obtain
Utilizing the system (12), we have
The Lyapunov–Lasalle theorem implies that solutions in Ω approach the largest positively invariant subset of the set \(V ' =0\), i.e., the plane \(I =0\). In this plane, \(S \rightarrow \frac{A}{d}\) as \(t \rightarrow \infty \). Thus all solutions in the plane \(I =0\) go to the diseasefree equilibrium \(E_{0}\). Therefore \(E_{0}\) is globally asymptotically stable. □
4 Existence and uniqueness of the solution
Applying the ABfractional integral on both sides of (12), we obtain
By using Proposition 2.1, we have
Using Eq. (3) in the above, we find
and
where
The above system of Eqs. (32)–(33) is the solution of the systems of Eq. (12),
Let \(C [ 0, T ]\) with subnorm be a Banach space of the real valued continuous functions. \(M = C [ 0, T ] \times C [ 0, T ]\) with the norm \(\Vert ( S, I ) \Vert = \Vert S \Vert + \Vert I \Vert , \Vert S \Vert = \sup_{t\in [ 0, T ]} \vert S ( t ) \vert \) and \(\Vert I \Vert = \sup_{t\in [ 0, T ]} \vert I ( t ) \vert \).
Theorem 4.1
The kernels, \(M_{1} ( \alpha,t,S ( t ),I ( t ) )\) and \(M_{2} ( \alpha,t,S ( t ),I ( t ) )\), satisfy the Lipschitz condition and contraction if the following inequality holds:
Proof
Consider \(M_{1} ( \alpha,t,S ( t ),I ( t ) ) = A^{\alpha }  \frac{\beta ^{\alpha } IS}{k+I}  \mu ^{\alpha } S\), Let \(S ( t )\) and \(S^{*} ( t )\) be two functions, then we have
where \(L_{1} = \Vert \mu ^{\alpha } + \frac{\beta ^{\alpha } I}{k+I} \Vert \) is bounded since \(I(t)\) is bounded, hence the Lipschitz condition is satisfied. If \(0\leq L_{1} <1\), then \(M_{1} ( \alpha,t,S ( t ),I ( t ) )\) becomes a contraction mapping. Similarly, for \(M_{2} ( \alpha,t,S ( t ),I ( t ) )\), we find
where
Since \(S ( t ), I ( t )\) and \(I^{*} ( t )\) are bounded, hence the Lipschitz condition is satisfied, if \(0\leq L_{2} <1\), \(M_{2} ( \alpha,t,S ( t ),I ( t ) )\) becomes a contraction mapping. □
Theorem 4.2
Suppose that the following condition holds:
Then the fractional epidemic model (12) has a unique solution for \(t\in [ 0,T ]\).
Proof
Recursively, the expressions in (35) can be written as
As usual taking the difference of successive approximations, we obtain
It is not difficult to see that \(S_{n} ( t ) = \sum_{i}^{n} \Pi _{i}^{S}\) and \(I_{n} ( t ) = \sum_{i}^{n} \Pi _{i}^{I}\), taking the sup norm on both sides, and using the Lipschitz condition on kernel functions and triangle inequality, we obtain
Starting from \(n=1\), we obtain by back substitution from (30) and (31), respectively,
and
It is clear from our hypothesis that \(\Vert \Pi _{n}^{S} \Vert \rightarrow 0\) and \(\Vert \Pi _{n}^{I} \Vert \rightarrow 0\) as \(n\rightarrow \infty \). We obtain a convergent series as follows:
and
Since \(r_{i} <1\), \(S_{n} ( t ), I_{n} ( t )\) are a Cauchy series in \(C [ 0,T ]\), and this series is uniformly convergent, it has a unique limit (Adams). So as \(n\rightarrow \infty \), in Eq. (18), \(S_{n} ( t )\) and \(I_{n} ( t )\) have unique fixed points and therefore the system in (7) has a solution and this solution in unique. □
5 Numerical results and discussion
In this section, we present the result, for which we use COVID19 data. The approach developed in [31] is used to approximate the ABC integral. We first use the fundamental theorem on the system (6) and obtain
and
At time \(t= t_{m+1}, m=0,1,\ldots \) , we obtain following iterative scheme:
Now, the function \(M_{i} ( \alpha,\tau,S ( \tau ),I ( \tau ) )\) is approximated by Lagrange interpolation on \([ t_{n}, t_{n+1} ]\) as
Substituting (55) into (53)–(54) and by integration, we have
5.1 Simulation
Case I: The world
We need to use real data for COVID19 to determine the parameters, the current birth rate for the world in 2020 is 18.077 births per 1000 people, and the death rate is 7.612 per 1000 people [16]. The world’s population on February was \(N = 7{,}610{,}105{,}452\), so \(A= \frac{n\times N}{365} =391{,}347, \mu = \frac{7.612}{365\times 1000} =2.08547\times 10^{5}\), according the WHO report [32] the COVID19 mortality rate \(\gamma =0.034\). The other parameters can be found by a curve fitting technique with real reported data for COVID19. Figure 1(a) shows the development of susceptible individuals decrease with the time as expected for integerorder derivatives, \(b=100\) and \(R_{0} =2.618\). Figure 1(b) shows the variations of infected individuals with the time, it increases with time and reaches the plateau region as seen in each country, where we used same parameters as Fig. 1(a). We compare the prediction fractionalorder derivatives in Fig. 2. It is well known that an increase in the number of active cases and reaching the plateau region are different for each country and the number of suspected population decreases and reaches the steady case. This is also different for each country. On the other hand, from Fig. 2, it is clear that the active or suspected population not only is a function of time but also a function of the fractional order. This fact proves that the fractionalorder derivative can be used the adjust the modeling to the different countries. The other point for fractionalorder derivative can also be used as a free parameter to fix the modeling with the data. The effect of the hospital beds for controlling of the diseases are given in Fig. 3(a)–(b). Figure 3(a) shows the difference of the results between \(b=100\) and \(b=10{,}000\). In Fig. 3(a) we show the infected individuals’ difference between \(b=100\) and \(b=10{,}000\) could reach 400,000 daily cases, if we assume that only 20% of infected individuals need medical treatment at hospital, then, if we multiply this one by COVID19 mortality rate 0.034, we obtain 2720 people life can be saved if we provide sufficient hospital beds. Figure 3(b) shows the difference of the suspected individual results of \(b=100\) and \(b=10{,}000\), this is expected because active infected cases for \(b=100\) always are bigger than active infected cases for \(b=10{,}000\). We also note that our numerical results converge to the disease equilibrium point.
Case 2: Saudi Arabia
In the second case, we provide a numerical simulation using real data for the transmission model of COVID19 in Saudi Arabia. According to the WHO report, the total population of Saudi Arabia \(N =34{,}218{,}169\) so \(A= \frac{n\times N}{365} = \frac{0.01335\times 3{,}418{,}169}{365} =1252, \mu = \frac{0.0133564}{365} =3.6593\times 10^{5}\), we assumed COVID19 mortality rate \(\gamma =0.034\). On April 8, \(I(0)=2260\) and \(S(0)=34{,}218{,}169\). In Fig. 4(b), we explored the prediction of active cases for different values of fractional order, \(\alpha =1\) (blue line), 0.9 (red line), 0.7 (black line) and 0.5 (green line), when we compare modeling prediction with the real data (WHO report active cases in Saudi Arabia [32]), we see that model prediction overestimate sometimes lower estimate, but again it seems that \(\alpha =0.9\) produces the best result. At this point, we note that even our suggested modeling seems simple, but we believe that prediction of this model can be used as a basis for more complicated model predictions. Furthermore, we have one more adjustable parameters in fractionalorder derivatives, this gives us enormous flexibility. Further, in Fig. 5, we concentrate on the effect of half saturation constant k over the suspected and infected individual for several values of fractional order of the derivations. We can see as before the effect of the fractional order provides us with enough flexibility and suspected individuals decrease with time and eventually reach the equilibrium point as we expected again the time to reach the equilibrium point to depend on the fractional order of the derivative.
6 Conclusion
In this study, consideration is given to a complex mathematical fractional SIR model for spreading of the COVID19 virus, we first show the feasibility region where the solution exists. The equilibrium points (diseasefree and endemic equilibrium) of the system are found. The local and global asymptotic stability of the system are discussed. Using the fixedpoint theorem, existence and uniqueness of solution is proven. A numerical solution of the system is performed for several values of the parameters involved in the modeling. We showed the importance of maintaining a sufficient number of hospital beds. We also discussed and compared the prediction of our modeling with real word data. Finally, we concluded that using the fractional derivative provides us with one more parameter, which can be used to simulate the real word data.
Availability of data and materials
The authors confirm that the data supporting the findings of this study are available within the article [and/or] its supplementary materials.
References
Brauer, F., CastilloChavez, C.: Mathematical Models in Population Biology and Epidemiology (2001)
Bonyah, E., Khan, M.A., Okosun, K.O., et al.: A theoretical model for Zika virus transmission. PLoS ONE 12, 1–26 (2017)
Baleanu, D., Mohammadi, H., Rezapour, S.: A mathematical theoretical study of a particular system of Caputo–Fabrizio fractional differential equations for the Rubella disease model. Adv. Differ. Equ. 184, 1–19 (2020)
Giordano, G., Blanchini, F., Bruno, R., Colaneri, P., Di Filippo, A., Di Matteo, A.: Modelling the COVID19 epidemic and implementation of populationwide interventions in Italy. Nat. Med. 26, 855–860 (2020)
Alshammari, F.S.: A mathematical model to investigate the transmission of COVID19 in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Comput. Math. Methods Med. 2020, Article ID 9136157 (2020)
Memon, Z., Qureshi, S., Memon, B.R.: Assessing the role of quarantine and isolation as control strategies for COVID19 outbreak: a case study. Chaos Solitons Fractals 144, 110655 (2021)
Kumar, D., Singh, J., Baleanu, D.: A new analysis of FornbergWhitham equation pertaining to a fractional derivative with MittagLeffler type kernel. Eur. Phys. J. Plus 133(2), 70 (2018)
Khan, M.A., Ullah, S., Ullah, S., Farhan, M.: Fractional order SEIR model with generalized incidence rate. AIMS Math. 5(4), 2843 (2020)
Goulart, A.G., Lazo, M.J., Suarez, J.M.S.: A new parameterization for the concentration flux using the fractional calculus to model the dispersion of contaminants in the planetary boundary layer. Physica A 518, 38–49 (2019)
Sene, N.: Analysis of a fractionalorder chaotic system in the context of the Caputo fractional derivative via bifurcation and Lyapunov exponents. J. King Saud Univ., Sci. 33(1), 101275 (2021)
Sene, N., Ndiaye, A.: On class of fractionalorder chaotic or hyperchaotic systems in the context of the Caputo fractionalorder derivative. J. Math. 2020, Article ID 8815377 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/8815377
Lü, J., Chen, G., Cheng, D.: A new chaotic system and beyond: the generalized Lorenzlike system. Int. J. Bifurc. Chaos 14(5), 1507–1537 (2004)
Atangana, A., Baleanu, D.: New fractional derivatives with nonlocal and nonsingular kernel: theory and application to heat transfer model. Therm. Sci. 20(2), 763–769 (2016)
Baleanu, D., Fernandez, A.: On some new properties of fractional derivatives with Mittag–Leffler kernel. Commun. Nonlinear Sci. Numer. Simul. 59, 444–462 (2018)
Khan, M.A., Ismail, M., Ullah, S., Farhan, M.: Fractional order SIR model with generalized incidence rate. AIMS Math. 5(3), 1856–1880 (1856)
Kumar, D., Singh, J., Tanwar, K., Baleanu, D.: A new fractional exothermic reactions model having constant heat source in porous media with power, exponential and MittagLeffler laws. Int. J. Heat Mass Transf. 138, 1222–1227 (2019)
Atangana, E., Atangana, A.: Facemasks simple but powerful weapons to protect against COVID19 spread: can they have sides effects? Results Phys. 19, 103425 (2020)
Khan, M.A., Atangana, A., Fatmawati, E.A.: The dynamics of COVID19 with quarantined and isolation. Adv. Differ. Equ. 1, 435 (2020)
Sene, N.: SIR epidemic model with Mittag–Leffler fractional derivative. Chaos Solitons Fractals 137, 109833 (2020)
Naik, P.A., Yavuz, M., Qureshi, S., Zu, J., Townley, S.: Modeling and analysis of COVID19 epidemics with treatment in fractional derivatives using real data from Pakistan. Eur. Phys. J. Plus 135, Article ID 795 (2020)
Bas, E., Acay, B., Ozarslan, R.: Fractional models with singular and nonsingular kernels for energy efficient buildings. Chaos 29, 023110 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5082390
Podlubny, I.: Fractional Differential Equations: An Introduction to Fractional Derivatives, Fractional Differential Equations, to Methods of Their Solution and Some of Their Applications. Elsevier, Amsterdam (1999)
Samko, S.G., Kilbas, A.A., Marichev, O.I.: Fractional Integrals and Derivatives: Theory and Applications (1993)
Hadeler, K.P., van den Driessche, P.: Backword bifurcation in epidemic control. Math. Biosci. 146, 15–35 (1997)
Hethcote, H.W.: The mathematics of infectious disease. SIAM Rev. 42, 599–653 (2000)
Liu, H., Hetchote, H.W., Levin, S.: Influence of nonlinear incidence rates upon the behavior of SIRS epidemiological model. J. Math. Biol. 23, 187–204 (1986)
Ruan, S., Wang, W.: Dynamical behavior of an epidemic model with a nonlinear incidence rate. J. Differ. Equ. 188, 135–163 (2003)
Tang, Y., Huang, D., Ruan, S., Zhang, W.: Coexistence of limit cycles and homoclinic loops in a SIRS model with a nonlinear incidence rate. SIAM J. Appl. Math. 69, 621–639 (2008)
Rao, F., Mandal, P.S., Kang, Y.: Complicated endemics of an SIRS model with a generalized incidence under preventive vaccination and treatment controls. Appl. Math. Model. 67, 38–61 (2019)
Shan, C., Zhu, H.: Bifurcations and complex dynamics of an SIR model with the impact of the number of hospital beds. J. Differ. Equ. 257, 1662–1688 (2014)
Toufik, M., Atangana, A.: New numerical approximation of fractional derivative with nonlocal and nonsingular kernel: application to chaotic models. Eur. Phys. J. Plus 132, 444 (2017)
Worldometer: COVID19 coronavirus pandemic. American Library Association. https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus
Acknowledgements
We thank the anonymous reviewers for the helpful comments on earlier drafts of the manuscript.
Funding
This research was supported by the Deanship of Scientific Research, Imam Mohammad Ibn Saud Islamic University (IMSIU), Saudi Arabia, Grant No. (211318005).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
FTA: Conceptualization, methodology, numerical simulations, writing the original draft. FA: Conceptualization, methodology, numerical simulations, writing the original draft. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Akyildiz, F.T., Alshammari, F.S. Complex mathematical SIR model for spreading of COVID19 virus with MittagLeffler kernel. Adv Differ Equ 2021, 319 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13662021034701
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13662021034701